• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Blog

Logo 1 Created with Sketch.

  • About
  • Our Lawyers
    • Andrew Wray
    • Juan Echavarria
    • Salman Rana
  • Expertise
    • Employment Law
    • Civil Litigation
    • COVID-19 Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Book a Consultation
LTD Benefits unreasonably withheld punitive damages employment law wray legal

Mental Distress and Punitive Damages. if LTD benefits are unreasonably withheld.

December 29, 2020 Tags: Employment Law, Long-Term Disability Benefits, LTD Benefits

What happens if LTD benefits are unreasonably withheld?

Where policy holders have been forced to commence litigation against the insurance company due to the denial of their LTD benefits, they may also seek damages for mental distress and punitive damages. These claims seek compensation for unfair treatment or unreasonable delays caused by the insurance provider. For example, where the policy holder shows that he or she should have received benefits from the moment they made a claim, or that they should not have been cut-off from benefits, they may be awarded damages for mental distress and/or punitive damages, in addition to any lump sum payment for retroactive and future LTD benefits.

The Supreme Court of Canada held in Fidler v. Sun Life, that a contract for long-term disability insurance is a “peace of mind contract”.  The reason for this, is that the purpose of LTD insurance is the have peace of mind provided by having income protection. The Court held in Fidler that the availability of mental distress and punitive damages in LTD litigation flows from the breach of the peace of mind contract.

Mental distress damages and punitive damages differ in that the first is meant to compensate the policy holder for his or her suffering, while the latter, as the name suggest, is meant to punish the insurance provider where its conduct warrants it.

The Court in Fidler established that due to the nature of disability insurance contracts, as “peace of mind contracts”, the parties would have contemplated at the time the contract was entered into that mental distress would result if the insurance provider refused to pay benefits to the policy holder when it should have. As a result, it is common for plaintiffs in LTD insurance claims to seek this kind of damages.

Punitive damages on the other hand are reserved for situations where the conduct of the insurance company constitutes a “marked departure from the ordinary standards of decency” giving rise to an “independent actionable wrong”. In the LTD litigation context, the Courts have found that insurance providers owe a duty of good faith which requires it to address a policy holder’s claim fairly. A breach of the duty to act in good faith has been determined to constitute an independent actionable wrong. Therefore, where the Court finds that the insurance provider has failed or refused to deal with a claim fairly, breaching its duty of good faith, it may award punitive damages.

However, simply denying a claim that is later determined by a Court to have merit is not by itself a failure to act in good faith. Punitive damages are reserved for particularly egregious conduct. For example, punitive damages have been awarded against insurance companies where it was shown that LTD benefits were denied, not on the merits of the claim, but in order to pressure the policy holder to settle the claim for less than the policy entitlement. It can be difficult to establish a claim for punitive damages as the threshold set by the Courts, regarding what conduct warrants it, is quite high.

We regularly advise our clients throughout the litigation of LTD claims and the damages available for their specific circumstances. You may contact us at any time with your LTD questions.

 

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Does My Original Contract Still Apply After 15 Years of Employment?
  • Mass Layoffs: Know the Law, Know your Rights
  • Severance pay in Ontario: What if I am fired for cause?
  • Should Companies update their Employment Contracts?
  • Non-competition Agreements Restricted under the Employment Standards Act

Tags

Blog Civil Litigation Constructive Dismissal Covid Employment Law Covid Mental Health Covid Wrongful Termination Employment Employment Contract Employment Law Health and Safety Human Rights Juan Echavarria Just Cause Termination Limitation Period Long-Term Disability Benefits LTD Benefits LTD Insurance Benefits Mechanical Business News Resignation Sale of Business Severance Pay Stock Options Termination Law termination notice Termination rights Total Disability wrongful dismissal

Footer

Contact Us

181 University Avenue, Suite 2200 Toronto, Ontario Canada M5H 3M7

T 416-642-0460
F 416-363-7875

Contact Page LinkedIn
Book a Consultation





    Please note that contact through our website is for informational purpose only and does not create a lawyer-client relationship.

    * Required

    [anr_nocaptcha g-recaptcha-response]

    Reviews

    Clecia Louzado
    Clecia Louzado
    2021-05-10
    Andrew is very professional, knowledgeable, fair and straightforward. I was grateful for his ability to outline all my options clearly and also his professionalism during a difficult time in his personal life. He did not let his personal life affect any time sensitive needs of my case, which didn’t go unnoticed. Highly recommend Andrew!
    Anton Koschany
    Anton Koschany
    2021-02-21
    Andrew Wray provided thorough analysis of my circumstances and provided sound advice. He is personable, knowledgeable and took the stress out of a stressful situation. In my professional career I have had occasion to work with many lawyers and I can easily say that Andrew meets and exceeds the bar (pardon the pun). Anton K.
    Lamrana Bah
    Lamrana Bah
    2021-02-02
    I had a very positive experience with the staff at Wray Legal LLP. Andrew Wray is a very brilliant bilingual lawyer. I was in search of a French Speaking lawyer and I came across him. He is a good listener, very professional with patience and passion for his job. I am grateful I met you. Thanks to you and your staff for your exceptional services 🙂
    Jamie Saunders
    Jamie Saunders
    2021-01-21
    Andrew Wray came highly recommended and now I know why! Andrew took a personal and very supportive approach as he helped to guide me through a long and challenging labour hearing process that had already cost me too many sleepless nights. His demonstrated understanding of the complex legal and procedural issues gave me tremendous confidence. Having never previously testified or given evidence, his advice on what I could expect on the stand was worth its weight in gold. I was kept completely in the loop with regard to strategies and next steps, and was always made to feel like I was steering the ship - with Andrew as my formidable engine. Oh, and by the way, we won the case! 🙂
    Mark Cuff
    Mark Cuff
    2020-12-19
    I am also highly recommending Wray Legal. Andrew represented me in a complicated employment matter - he was extremely responsive, and knowledgable in offering excellent legal advice. Andrew explained/outlined thoroughly what to expect and worked to make sure I was getting the very best outcome. I really liked how very realistic he was about my options and which would be the most beneficial to my specific situation. Wray Legal came highly recommended from friends and I can see why. Excellent experience
    Jennifer Morrison
    Jennifer Morrison
    2020-12-18
    Andrew and his team were there for me at a very difficult time. Andrew is always kind and compassionate, while understanding the job that needs to be done. I was very pleased with the outcome of my case. When it comes to a legal team, you want the best in your corner and Andrew is the best! I would highly recommend calling Andrew to see how his team can get the best settlement for you, I’m glad I did!
    Richard Goodman
    Richard Goodman
    2020-12-18
    Andrew helped me to resolve a complicated legal dispute with a former employer. Andrew was extremely professional is all of his dealings with me and opposing counsel. Andrew treated me as a partner, not just a client. It was an extremely positive experience and outcome, especially considering the difficult nature of the dispute. Thanks for all your help, Andrew!
    Tamara Roitman
    Tamara Roitman
    2020-12-11
    Andrew represented me through a workplace issue during a very low point in my life. From a legal standpoint he was extremely knowledgeable and professional. More than that, however, he was kind, gentle and understanding.  Having a lawyer that not only knew what he was doing, but who is also a good human being who went above and beyond to communicate and offer emotional support was the best possible thing both for the outcome of my case as well as for my mental health. I will always feel grateful to Andrew and his firm.
    © 2023 Wray Legal