• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Blog

Logo 1 Created with Sketch.

  • About
  • Our Lawyers
    • Andrew Wray
    • Juan Echavarria
    • Salman Rana
  • Expertise
    • Employment Law
    • Civil Litigation
  • Blog
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • Contact Us
  • Book a Consultation
Constructive-Dismissal-Covid-Employment-Law-Wray-Legal

Constructive Dismissal A COVID Caselaw Update

May 7, 2021 Tags: Constructive Dismissal, Covid Employment Law, Employment Law

As a result of the COVID pandemic, the government of Ontario modified the Employment Standards Act (ESA) to create a new form of leave, being the “Infectious Disease Emergency Leave”. The new regulations exempted employees who were temporarily laid off for reasons related to COVID, from eligibility to termination and severance pay. Instead, temporarily laid off employees were deemed to be on the Infectious Disease Emergency Leave and would not be considered to have been constructively dismissed. For further discussion regarding the Infectious Disease Emergency Leave, please refer to our blog: “Laid Off During COVID: what are my rights?”.

Prior to these ESA changes, employees who were temporarily laid off had two options. First, employees could wait for 13 weeks, or 35 weeks in some cases, and if they were not recalled by their employer, employees were entitled to termination pay, and severance pay, where applicable. Second, at common law, employees did not have to wait for 13 weeks, or 35 weeks, as the case may be, but instead could choose to make a civil claim for pay in lieu of reasonable notice. As a result of the new regulations, employees no longer have the first option. While the new regulations are in place, employees can now be laid off in excess of the 13 or 35 weeks, and employers do not have to pay termination or severance pay, as long as the reason for the lay off was related to COVID. However, many wondered whether the new ESA rules would affect employees’ right, at common law, being the second option, to make a wrongful or constructive dismissal claim, seeking pay in lieu of reasonable notice where the employee was temporarily laid off during the COVID pandemic.

The Superior Court of Justice, in Coutinho v. Ocular Health Centre Ltd., has recently held that, despite the changes to the ESA, employees’ rights under the common law are unaffected, and they may still bring a claim for pay in lieu of reasonable notice.

In the Coutinho case, the employer argued that, given the unprecedented nature of the COVID pandemic, and its effect on workplaces, the new ESA regulations, should be interpreted to apply to temporary layoffs under the ESA, as well as the common law. However, the Court rejected this proposition on two grounds; first, the provisions of the ESA, specifically, section 8(1), state that “no civil remedy of an employee against his or her employer is affected by this Act [the ESA]”; and second, the Court relied on extrinsic evidence, being the Ministry of Labour’s guide to the new ESA regulations, which specifically indicated that the rules only affect what constitutes a constructive dismissal under the ESA, and not the common law. While the latter was not a binding authority, the Court relied on it to assist in the interpretation of the Ministry of Labour’s intention when enacting the new ESA regulations.

As a result, the Court in Coutinho refused the employer’s assertion that the ESA provisions should extend to the common law due to the extraordinary circumstances regarding the COVID pandemic. Instead, the Court upheld the well-established principle that, absent an agreement to the contrary, the employer cannot unilaterally lay off an employee, and doing so would constitute a substantial change in the employment which amounts to a constructive dismissal.

As more cases are heard by the Courts, regarding employment issues arising during, and because of, the COVID pandemic, employees will be better informed regarding their rights where their jobs may have been affected during this time. As lawyers with expertise in employment law, we continue to advise our clients regarding their ability to pursue a claim where their employment was terminated or substantially changed as a result of COVID. You may contact us at any time with your questions.

 

 

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Am I entitled to termination pay if I am fired for cause?
  • Should Companies update their Employment Contracts?
  • Non-competition Agreements Restricted under the Employment Standards Act
  • Termination during COVID can result in longer notice periods
  • Am I entitled to Severance Pay? Update to law of Severance

Tags

Blog Civil Litigation Constructive Dismissal Covid Employment Law Covid Mental Health Covid Wrongful Termination Employment Employment Law Health and Safety Human Rights Juan Echavarria Just Cause Termination Limitation Period Long-Term Disability Benefits LTD Benefits LTD Insurance Benefits Mechanical Business News Resignation Sale of Business Severance Pay Stock Options termination notice Total Disability wrongful dismissal

Footer

Contact Us

181 University Avenue, Suite 2200 Toronto, Ontario Canada M5H 3M7

T 416-642-0460
F 416-363-7875

Contact Page LinkedIn
Book a Consultation






    Please note that contact through our website is for informational purpose only and does not create a lawyer-client relationship.

    * Required

    Reviews

    • I had the pleasure of working with Andrew & his team and I could not be more thankful for having them represent me during a very trying time. They were very knowledgeable and helped guide me thru the entire process. Going thru any legal issue can be very emotionally draining but knowing I had Andrew on my side def helped ease my anxiety. In the end, Andrew was able to win my dispute and I owe it all to his attention to detail and wealth of knowledge.

      Charlene De Silva

    • Robert Tarantino and his associates at Wray Legal handled my case against my former employer with compassion, ethically sound expert advice in plain language and professional courtesy during my termination process, a stressful event in any working person's life. I was presented with all potential courses of action during my initial meeting prior to making a decision to retain services, and was treated with respect and dignity every step of the way. Wray Legal was able to mediate an acceptable settlement without having to proceed with a formal human rights violation compliant at the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal. Thank you Robert, Andrew and Samantha.

      Ian G.

    • We contracted with Robert Tarantino of Wray Legal to do a respectful workplaces presentation to our organization. This was part of a follow up to a StressAssess.ca survey we had done with all of our staff. Robert’s presentation included: Introduction; Overview – Why ‘Respectful Workplaces’ is an Important Topic; What is a Respectful Workplace?; Occupational Health and Safety Act – workplace harassment; Human Rights Code – discrimination in employment; Fostering a Healthy and Respectful Workplace; and Q & A – Discussion. The presentation was extremely well done, very engaging and included excellent examples. Robert did an excellent job and I would highly recommend his services.

      Michael Roche

      CEO, Occupational Health Clinics for Ontario Workers

    • I am grateful to have worked with Andrew Wray on a Third Party Claim that was filed against me. While we arrived at a very amicable conclusion, it was a rather complex route to get there. Andrew was extremely patient with both me and the other party. His legal advice was insightful and he always acted in an extremely professional manner. I asked a lot of questions regarding law and process and Andrew always took the time to ensure that I was comfortable with both. I really had the feeling that he was actually working for me and looking out for my best interests. I would have no reservations about contacting Andrew again for help, nor would I have any reservations in recommending him to a friend or colleague. Many thanks!!

      KM

    • Andrew Wray helped me settle a dispute with my past employer which lead to a healthy settlement. I would recommend Andrew to anyone looking for a professional and cost-effective litigator.

      A Google User

    • Andrew Wray came highly recommended and now I know why! Andrew took a personal and very supportive approach as he helped to guide me through a long and challenging labour hearing process that had already cost me too many sleepless nights. His demonstrated understanding of the complex legal and procedural issues gave me a tremendous confidence. Having never previously testified or given evidence, his advice on what I could expect on the stand was worth its weight in gold. I was kepy completely in the loop with regard to strategies and next steps, and was always made to feel like I was steering the ship - with Andrew as my formidable engine. Oh, and by the way, we won the case! :)

      Jamie S.

    © 2023 Wray Legal
    Site by Cameron Duncalfe
    Privacy Policy